Welcome to Carelli's Pizza (Little Falls)
Carelli's Pizza in Little Falls, NJ, is a gem for pizza lovers and diners alike. Conveniently located at 101 Newark Pompton Turnpike, this spacious eatery offers a cozy ambiance with casual and elegant dining spaces. Known for its hot, fresh pizzas and an array of flavorful dishes, guests rave about the quality and authenticity of the food. Standout items like the bruschetta salad and chicken parmello highlight the diverse menu. The owner has recently renovated the restaurant, creating a clean and inviting environment. Plus, with BYOB options, it’s perfect for both late-night cravings and family gatherings.
Carelli's Pizza (Little Falls): Reviews & Ratings
I ordered some salads expecting typical style pizzeria salads, plain and uneventful. The place didn't disappoint. Salads were good, dressings were on point and the portions were just right for a late night meal.
Haven’t been here in a minute. Forgot how hot and fresh everything is. They renovated the place. It’s huge. Very clean. BYOB as well.
This place is sooo good me and my mom get pizza here all the time and their food such as chicken parm is amazing. Heavily recommend
This is a great restaurant. It has great pizza and great food in general. There’s casual dining in the front and a nice dining room in the back. Prices are reasonable too!
I've ordered here plenty of times because their food is authentic and very delicious. My favorite is the bruschetta salad with grilled shrimp. I even tried the stuffed mushrooms. Yummy! Its very nice and spacious inside and you can even dine alone too.
Friend ordered from this location for a party. The food was incredible. The grandma pie was one one the best I have had. The regular pie was also extremely tasty
Formerly GENcarelli’s but now Carelli’s, you will enjoy excellent Italian food at this spacious place which is much more than the “Pizza” name implies. Complimentary bread and butter include delicious fresh focaccia with tomatoes and rosemary. Generous and tasty soups and salads. Had the homemade rigatoni with Bolognese sauce which was yummy and perfectly al dente! Service was excellent, attentive but not overbearing. Very reasonable prices.
Wow! My first time here with my mom, we will definitely be back!! A great atmosphere, the dining room is beautiful with a stunning fireplace. And the service was absolutely amazing, our waitress Nesly (hope I'm spelling this right!) was super sweet and friendly. We tried the homemade rigatoni that was on special, and WOW! Wish I could give 10 stars lol. I ordered the focaccia panini, it's so delicious!! Definitely will be back soon!
Location
-
101 Newark Pompton Turnpike, Little Falls Township, NJ 07424, United States Hotline: +1 973-830-2703
Discover a local treasure at Carelli's Pizza in Little Falls, where authenticity meets flavor in an inviting atmosphere. Conveniently located at 101 Newark Pompton Turnpike, Little Falls Township, NJ, this eatery has built a reputation for serving hearty meals that put a twist on classic pizzeria fare. The spacious renovations have transformed the space into a clean, welcoming environment for all diners to enjoy.
Among the standout offerings at Carelli's, the pizza is a must-try. Each pie is crafted with fresh ingredients, embodying the essence of traditional Italian cooking. Customer reviews highlight not just the remarkable taste, but also the freshness and temperature of the dishes served. Surprising many, guests have found the salads to be exceptional—far beyond typical pizzeria standards. One diner remarked on the delightful dressings that complemented their meal perfectly, proving that Carelli's pays attention to even the smallest details.
But the culinary delights don’t stop there. With enticing options like the chicken parmesan and the recommended bruschetta salad topped with grilled shrimp, there’s something for every palate. The generous portions make dining here suitable for any occasion, whether it's a late-night craving or a casual family dinner. The ambiance also supports a relaxed dining experience, featuring both casual and slightly more refined seating areas.
Moreover, with a BYOB policy, you can easily pair your meal with your favorite drink, enhancing the overall dining experience. As Robert Graber noted, the cleanliness and spaciousness of Carelli's make it a comfortable spot for everyone, whether you’re dining solo or with family.
Carelli's Pizza is not just a restaurant; it's a community staple, where delicious, authentic food brings people together. I highly recommend making a stop at Carelli's, whether for a slice of their delicious pizza or a full feast that will leave you craving more.